Neethane En Ponvasantham | Yeto Vellipoyindhi Manasu | Assi Nabbe Poorey Sau

[krish244]

Pallavi portion with yuvan's style of singing is a bit of a let down. The song sounds better from anupallavi though. Lovely (and classy) guitar laden ludes.

Maybe there were reasons to select Yuvan. One I could think of is that he has given some nice melodies (in his music and his style of singing) in some movies in recent years and many people like it. I like his "pogadhe" song from deepavali immensely.

HEARTY BIRTHDAY WISHES to our beloved Ilaiyaraaja!

thanks,

Krishnan

[equanimus]

யுவன் நிறைய பாடல்கள் பாடிட்டாப்லயே. சமீப காலமா தான் அவர் பாடகரே கிடையாதுங்கறது அளவுல விமரிசனங்கள் தென்படுது. Or maybe I haven't been paying enough attention or following such discussions. ஆனா ஏதோ இடிக்குது.

[Plum]

யுவன் நிறைய பாடல்கள் பாடிட்டாப்லயே. சமீப காலமா தான் அவர் பாடகரே கிடையாதுங்கறது அளவுல விமரிசனங்கள் தென்படுது. Or maybe I haven't been paying enough attention or following such discussions. ஆனா ஏதோ இடிக்குது.

AmAyyA indha KArthik Raja fans (naanum Mumbai RAmkiyum) dhAn kaasu koduthu ellAraiyum apdi solla vaikkiROm

[equanimus]

Have nothing to say about the song itself. Except that it (the guitar) kinda sounds nice.

[equanimus]

Plum, I'm not saying there's an agenda or anything to that effect. Just wondering if Yuvan has overindulged himself over the years (by giving himself too many songs) and has annoyed many people enough to place such a criticism. யுவனுக்குன்னு ஒரு scope இருக்குறதா தான் எனக்குப் பட்டிருக்கு. Not a fan, but I've liked some of his songs. There, I said it.

[equanimus]

>>digr.
And as an aside, this whole polemic about Karthik Raja being a more proper heir of Raaja (or simply more Raaja-like) doesn't hold water IMO. And I'm someone who loves a good share of Karthik Raja's work, but Raaja-vudaiya signature style-la avar muzhusA imbibe paNNi compose paNRadhA thONala. adhula irukkuRa sila sparks irukku-ngRadhukku mEla solla edhuvum irukkAnnu theriyala. To my untrained ears, it seems he has his own style -- 'lite' compositions, inclination towards lethargic melodies and so on. 'kingudA' pAttellAm kEttuttuth thAn pEsuRIngaLA?
<<end digr.

[jaiganes]

>>digr.
And as an aside, this whole polemic about Karthik Raja being a more proper heir of Raaja (or simply more Raaja-like) doesn't hold water IMO. And I'm someone who loves a good share of Karthik Raja's work, but Raaja-vudaiya signature style-la avar muzhusA imbibe paNNi compose paNRadhA thONala. adhula irukkuRa sila sparks irukku-ngRadhukku mEla solla edhuvum irukkAnnu theriyala. To my untrained ears, it seems he has his own style -- 'lite' compositions, inclination towards lethargic melodies and so on. 'kingudA' pAttellAm kEttuttuth thAn pEsuRIngaLA?
<<end digr.

ennaya kaetta raasavoda isaikku vaarisu innyum varailnnu dhaan solvaen. varanumnaa - oru raakshasa dhaagam venum. "kondaadi andaa" rangekku paatayum isayaiyum kudikkara
oru modaa kudigaaran. avana maadhiri boadhayoda evanum illaingradhu dhaan factuu.

[P_R]

kingudA pAttellAm kEttuttuth thAn pEsuRIngaLA?

[equanimus]

I mean, really! Look at what Karthik Raja does with a kuththu song (how differently Prabhu Deva has to choreograph for it and so on). Of course there's a possibility that KR was asked to do so by the director (Sundar C!) and all that, but it's not like he does something truly startling within the given scope. Raaja OTOH is a proper monster in every which way possible in whatever scope he's offered. How many KR songs do you recall in which he's exhibited something close to such monstrosity?! avarukku iLagina manasu sir. In fact, all my responses to this startling claim can be summed up with this sentence. avarukku romba iLagina manasu sir.

[Plum]

VaarisunA orevadiyA sdburmanukku rdburman rangela edhirpArkaradhA?(Ninga innum mela poyi 16 adi paayanumnu vERa edhirpaarkaringa)? Edho or sivajikku prabhu, mgrku jayalalitha rangeukkAvadhu othukka koodaadhA? Paarthu pottu kodunga saar