Who is the worst MD-Deva,Sirpi,S.A.Rajkumar or Adhithyan?

Home Forum Wiki Notes Register FAQ Sitemap About Us Contact Us

Who is the worst MD-Deva,Sirpi,S.A.Rajkumar or Adhithyan? Who is the worst MD-Deva,Sirpi,S.A.Rajkumar or Adhithyan?

Topic started by subasree (@ 61.11.76.42) on Thu Aug 29 00:18:37 EDT 2002.
All times in EST +10:30 for IST.

This is a question which comes to my mind often.Can you please enlighten me on this matter

Responses:

From: Aswathama (@ 68.58.127.57) on: Thu Aug 29 04:39:24 EDT 2002

ARR is the worst MD and a good Sound engineer..
From: Are Yaar (@ 203.197.141.186) on: Thu Aug 29 05:01:53 EDT 2002

AWE wanted some answer.

Aswathama is the answer.
From: a (@ 156.153.254.42) on: Thu Aug 29 05:17:57 EDT 2002

ARR
From: Paran (@ 203.127.155.68) on: Thu Aug 29 05:22:28 EDT 2002

...athan A, B, C, D kuduthe choose panne sollrange thane....why u guys still pick E as an answer? After failing the exam, you guys feel bad..

hehehe
From: Voice of Reason (@ 210.186.60.224) on: Thu Aug 29 09:59:56 EDT 2002

I don't understand what joy can be gotten from nominating the worst? Nothing is black and white in this world - the best MDs have some totally lousy work while even bad MDs have some good songs. Wouldn't be better to see a half filled glass then a half empty glass?

Deva and SAR have contributed plenty of good memorable songs. However, I am not aware of Sirpy's and Adhithyan's good songs. Can we list some of their good and popular songs?

I remember Sirpy's "magazine" song - Kumutham pol....
The same movie had at least a couple of good songs. Anyone can remember?
From: Thiru (@ 63.169.243.35) on: Thu Aug 29 10:42:29 EDT 2002

I guess its sirpi... but again only morons pick an option E when they are asked to pick A,B,C & D....
From: x (@ 209.47.143.226) on: Thu Aug 29 11:36:33 EDT 2002

It's SA Rajkumar. He copies, recyles... most of the time he does 'oppaethal' (u know what I mean). He has become one of the famous MD merely by fluke... something has gone wrong wrong somewhere..

Then there is nothing to talk about Adhiyan. He hasn't done many movies but he changed his hair style to look like ARR, though...
From: MANJUNATH (@ 203.197.177.68) on: Sat Aug 31 03:20:35 EDT 2002

its SIRPY a best competent to BAPPI LAHIRI
From: Guru (@ 210.186.103.31) on: Sat Aug 31 13:39:10 EDT 2002

Today's Up coming Music Composers....

Harris Jayaraj
Kartik Raja
Yuvan Shangkar Raja
Bharadwaj
Dhina
D.Immanuel
Bhavadharani (Mitr My Friend)
Anuradha Sriram (Five Star)
Ramesh Vinayagam (his 1st Debut University)
From: Kum_Laden (@ 66.185.85.76) on: Sat Aug 31 14:33:55 EDT 2002

YSR is a veteran, he is already UP there!
From: MUSIC LOVER (@ 62.32.54.18) on: Fri Sep 6 11:14:42 EDT 2002

ARR IS THE WORST MUSIC DIRECTOR IN INDIA COS U HAVE MENTIONED DEVA AS A BAD MUSIC DIRECTOR AND ARR HAS LIFTED A DEVA TUNE DIRECTLY FOR BABA FRM ARUNACHALAM,SO IMAGINE WAT A DISGRACEFUL MD ARR IS,HANG THE BASTERD ARR
From: venki_1432@rediffmail.com (@ ) on: Mon Jan 12 13:47:40 EST 2004

IILAAY RAJA IS MUSIC AND MUSIC IS ILLAYARAJA, NO SECOND THOUGHT IN IT.
From: Kupps (@ 199.180.6.54) on: Mon Jan 12 15:52:39 EST 2004

**********************************************
...athan A, B, C, D kuduthe choose panne sollrange thane....why u guys still pick E as an answer?
**********************************************

what paran??? do u consider ARR as one of the top five worst MDs? even i dont consider him so.

And you too Thiru :-))

ARR fans, here are two traitor, beware of them. ;-))

Naarayana Naarayana Naaraayana :-)
From: jacky ...LOL! (@ 61.1.200.124) on: Mon Jan 12 16:37:52 EST 2004

have fun bashing ARR but its not going to help raja's cause, its not going to sell his albums.
Nor it will help him get international projects, i mean paid projects, not public fund projects like thiruvasakam.
From: Kupps (@ 199.180.6.54) on: Mon Jan 12 16:55:43 EST 2004

jacky jacky...cool it man...hope u looked at the smily almost at each line.

btw why shud all ARR bashers be IR fans -- how could u assume me so? ;-)

next level of Naarayana Naarayana Naaraayana :-)
From: jacky (@ 61.1.200.124) on: Mon Jan 12 16:59:25 EST 2004

Shiva shiva shiva :)
From: jacky (@ 61.1.200.124) on: Mon Jan 12 17:05:00 EST 2004

Venki 1432!

if illayaraja is music a then

kalayanji aanandji is music
boney m is music
sound of music is music
rd burman is music
micheal jackson is music
cos he has lifted from these guys.
From: KJ (@ 193.11.249.87) on: Mon Jan 12 18:09:34 EST 2004

and in that case ARRAHMAN would be a MP3 collection of world music
From: Kupps (@ 199.180.6.54) on: Mon Jan 12 19:08:05 EST 2004

'villan' veerappa: posting aeppidi
assistant: jacky's, pramaadham
'villan' veerappa: muttaaL KJ's?
assistant: KJ's!! adhi pramaadham adhi pramaadham
.....
.....
'villan' veerappa: ha!haaa! sabaash sariyaana pOtti.

******* A sudden jump from vanjikkottai to meenakshi ammai's madurai kottai **********

shenbagappaandiyan: postergaLae..grrr...pulavargaLae shanthamaaga vizhayaadungaL. Bashing-il veeriyam thaevaidhaan adhu personal-level-il irangi vidakkoodaadhu.
From: Kupps (@ 199.180.6.54) on: Mon Jan 12 19:08:55 EST 2004

TYPO:

it should be viLayaadungaL and not as posted
From: jacky ...LOL! (@ 61.1.200.130) on: Mon Jan 12 21:37:50 EST 2004

Athan pa
guru ippadiyo appadidhan shisyan
i am sorry to hear that Mp3 player in raja's house conked off :)
Too costly a price to pay!
From: C~P (@ 61.95.159.16) on: Tue Jan 13 08:54:33 EST 2004

Kupps,
paavam Paran and Thiru...2 years-ku munnadi pannina mistake-ku ippo dhandanai thevaiya?! :-)

"Naarayana Naarayana Naaraayana :-)"
kalagam seyyareenga...nanmayila mudinja seri! :-)
From: karthik (@ 203.197.141.34) on: Tue Jan 13 09:31:43 EST 2004

Guys,

Dont be stupid...

Raja is the best

but
you can say rehmann is worst...
he is

The MAN The MAGIC The MUSIC.....
From: C~P (@ 61.95.159.16) on: Tue Jan 13 13:14:31 EST 2004

onnumey puriyaley ulagathiley!
From: KP (@ 161.150.2.31) on: Tue Jan 13 13:21:48 EST 2004

The magic? Rahman eppoppa jaadugar aaanaru?:)
From: Sabesh-Murali (@ 62.243.89.202) on: Tue Jan 13 20:48:45 EST 2004

deva the worst md? lol! He might copy a lot but he has given great numbers like vandhenda paalkaaran, pulveli, kattipudi, vanna nilavae etc.

venki ir is not music, he is a more like a hardcore version of "mellisiai mannan" MSV
From: hary (@ 195.93.73.10) on: Mon Jan 19 03:54:22 EST 2004

Harris Jayaraj definitily!
From: hary (@ 195.93.73.10) on: Mon Jan 19 03:54:29 EST 2004

Harris Jayaraj definitily!
From: P C Sorcar (@ 61.95.159.16) on: Mon Jan 19 07:00:04 EST 2004

Kaun hai woh, mujko ..err.. 'poatti' dhey raha hain!
From: dinesh (@ 210.186.42.121) on: Mon Jan 19 08:45:22 EST 2004

hello,arr a bad md??then what is he doin composing for chinese & eng projects??and i mean,LOTR is the MAJOR in Eng industry!

From: Aswathama (@ 68.58.127.57) on: Thu Aug 29 04:39:24 EDT 2002

ARR is the worst MD and a good Sound engineer..
-i think ur a IR hardcore hardcore fan!i understand,but belive me,ARR is the best md & best sound engineer!!IR is nowhere near ARR in music!!and i mean it!
From: 12 (@ 66.185.84.78) on: Mon Jan 19 08:53:12 EST 2004

Who is the worst MD?? only ar rahman
From: ananth (@ 219.95.212.198) on: Mon Jan 19 10:11:15 EST 2004

ar rahman is god of music....
ar rahman is king of music...

the worst MD are ilaiyaraja n harris jeyaraj...
From: ananth (@ 219.95.212.198) on: Mon Jan 19 10:13:51 EST 2004

Aswathama...u r great

AR RAHMAN rocks the world...

ilayaraja n others booooooooooooo(nowhere near arr)
From: x (@ 203.200.195.2) on: Tue Jan 20 06:00:28 EST 2004

ARR
From: aishwarya (@ 202.156.2.122) on: Wed Jan 21 04:53:19 EST 2004

why do u say arr is the worst????!!!!who can compose gentlemen?duet?roja?etc etc etc...he is one of the best..trendsetter!i dun know which movies sirpi or adithyan composed..so i wud say s.a rajkumar...
From: nayakan (@ 61.1.202.37) on: Wed Jan 21 05:13:44 EST 2004

Even IR and ARR get along folks, for the launch of ARR's Jana gana mana in 2000 IR and MSV were invited.

No more vichu arivals ;)

Neruthunaga - ellathiyun neruthunga ;)
From: x (@ 203.200.195.2) on: Wed Jan 28 03:23:28 EST 2004

poda nayakan....
Worst is ARR only for Music.
From: C~P (@ 61.95.159.16) on: Wed Jan 28 09:25:04 EST 2004

Ithellam Tamizhnattoda kalaacharam-ya kalaachaaram...ungalai ellam thiruththavey mudiyaathu! :-)

List all pages of this thread

Back to the Forum

Post comments

Sections: Home - TFM Magazine - Forum - Wiki - POW - oPod - Lyrics - Pictures - Music Notes -
Forums: Current Topics - Ilayaraja Albums - A.R. Rahman Albums - TFM Oldies - Fun & Games
Ilaiyaraja: Releases - News - Share Music - AR Rahman: Releases - News - AOTW - Tweets -
Discussions: MSV - YSR - GVP - Song Requests - Song stats - Raga of songs - Copying - Tweets
Database: Main - Singers - Music Director's - Lyricists Fun: PP - EKB - Relay - Satires - Quiz