<b>Rating Of Singers</b>

Home Forum Wiki Notes Register FAQ Sitemap About Us Contact Us

<b>Rating Of Singers</b> Rating Of Singers

Topic started by Rajesh Kumar (@ 198.151.230.253) on Thu Mar 1 03:33:16 EST 2001.
All times in EST +10:30 for IST.

We can Rate The Singers According to the Following Categories..

Singing:10 points

Pronounciation 10 points

Variation :10 points

Modulation : 10 Points

Versatality : 10 Points

Total should be 50....

Responses:

Old responses
From: Meera krishna (@ 205.227.43.13) on: Wed Mar 14 20:59:51 EST 2001

S.JANAKI is always BEST

Voice-10
Pronounciation-10
Variation-10
Bhavam-10
Modulation-10
Versatality-10

Total Scoring is 60/60

LONG LIVE MELODY QUEEN.
From: shiva (@ 202.54.84.65) on: Wed Mar 14 23:23:43 EST 2001

I agree with Meera Krishna
S.JANAKI is the best singer
100% perfection in each an every song
LONG LIVE MELODY QUEEN
From: rajeshkumar (@ 198.151.230.253) on: Thu Mar 15 04:15:23 EST 2001

I Cannot Agree With MEera/shiva
if that is the Case I give 200/100 for P.susheela

My next Pick is Mano

Singing : 9 points

Pronounciation : 9 points

Variation : 9 points

Modulation : 8 Points

Versatality : 9 Points

Totally he scores 44/50
From: ffgg (@ 203.199.130.71) on: Thu Mar 15 10:44:56 EST 2001

to all people,
You all seem to be pretty liberal in giving marks, eh !!!!!!!!!I wish you were my exam-paper
correctors!!!!!
From: Meera Krishna (@ 205.227.43.15) on: Thu Mar 15 20:52:22 EST 2001

Mr Rajesh you can give 1000/10 to PS because you liked her songs. But I love SJ songs so that I will give her full marks OK.If you agree or not who cares
.
From: rajeshkumar (@ 198.151.230.253) on: Thu Mar 15 23:13:00 EST 2001

hello Meerakrishna when the topic is rating
u shld split & give marks perfectly
just saying 100/10 etc is not the correct way

Ok No body asked u to Care.................

Pls b polite in the Discussion Forum
From: Fliflo (@ 130.203.161.113) on: Thu Mar 15 23:18:44 EST 2001

Podunga! Alli, Alli Podunga...Kaasa, Panama....summa alli veesunga!
From: shiva (@ 202.54.84.65) on: Thu Mar 15 23:35:40 EST 2001

hi Rajesh,
Your fav singer is PS
We know that already
Now she can not give a good song
Because the sweetness in her voice gone
Evergreen melody queen is S.Janaki
From: rajeshkumar (@ 198.151.230.253) on: Mon Mar 19 01:21:42 EST 2001

HAI SHIVA AS IF SJ IS HAVING A SWEET VOICE..
IT'S HAS DETERIORATED TO 100% ..WHEREAS HEAR PS IN KANNUKU MAI AZHAGU..OH GOD...
From: Purnima Ramani (@ 210.214.4.69) on: Mon Mar 19 21:35:16 EST 2001

UnniKrishnan
1.S...-10
2.p...-9.5
3.Va..-9
4.M...-10
5.Ve..-9
Total:47.5/50
Thank You
Bye
From: ppb (@ 63.253.16.5) on: Mon Mar 19 22:21:19 EST 2001

Purnima, go and study for your exams.
PSusheela
1.S...-1
2.p...-1
3.Va..-1
4.M...-1
5.Ve..-1
Total:5/50

SJanaki
1.S...-10
2.p...-10
3.Va..-10
4.M...-10
5.Ve..-10
Total : 50/50

Hail SJanaki.
Bye see you all later.
From: rajeshk (@ 198.151.230.253) on: Tue Mar 20 03:46:01 EST 2001

PSusheela
1.S...-10
2.p...-10
3.Va..-10
4.M...-10
5.Ve..-10
Total:50/50

SJanaki
1.S...-0.5
2.p...-0.5
3.Va..-0.5
4.M...-0.5
5.Ve..-0.5
Total : 2.5/50
From: G.Ragavan (@ 164.164.128.13) on: Tue Mar 20 06:15:40 EST 2001

Not only "Kannuku Mai Azaku" Rajashekar,
Aaya Kalaikal Arupathu Nankinaium from Duet
Kappalerip Poyachu from Indian.
Koonda Vittu Oru Parava from Kattabomman.
From: shankar (@ ) on: Mon Apr 23 08:01:28 EDT 2001

though s.janaki is a good singer she can never be
equal or compared to melody queen p.susheela
she is always laggeing behind p.susheela and it is
a universal true and can ask any film personality
about this janaki is singing just from 80's that too is because of IR.
From: sats (@ 139.177.224.100) on: Mon Apr 23 09:51:54 EDT 2001

adada i always thought there was only IR vs ARR , ippo SJ vs PS kuda irukka

pavam sj & ps nenacha rombo pavama irukku
From: unmaivilambi (@ 63.75.49.120) on: Mon Apr 23 10:27:43 EDT 2001

The greatness of a singer lies in maintaining the voice and also show emotions. Today PS has a junk voice and she has never shown the required emotions in her voice unlike SJ who is always the best.
From: Bharath (@ 192.25.158.12) on: Mon Apr 23 12:51:41 EDT 2001

Hi,

I used to like s.janaki but now she is old and her voice really sux, especially in the song "oru naal antha oru naal" I wish she stops singing and spoil her name further.

c'mon guys ! she is not the old s.janaki! now her voice is as bad as vani jayaram

bye
bharath
From: Bharath (@ 192.25.158.12) on: Mon Apr 23 12:54:05 EDT 2001

hi,

here is my list
Favorite male singers of the future
1) hariharan
2) shankar mahadevan
3) the ever green SPB

female singers
1) swarnalatha , she is good give her a break
2) bombay jayashre is good but sings less
3)harini, she is really cool
4) pavatharini , i like her voice
From: Meera Krishna (@ 148.87.1.170) on: Mon Apr 23 21:08:40 EDT 2001

Melody Queen PS is always lagging behind SJ in Kannada Industry, SJ is one who sing 75% of kannada duets with Dr Rajkumar.PS has sung only 3 songs with him.I think this is the Universal true.
From: Neel (@ 64.3.192.164) on: Mon Apr 23 23:31:23 EDT 2001

Dr.Rajkumar is no TMS, is he?
From: mani (@ 203.200.15.20) on: Tue Apr 24 00:21:47 EDT 2001

see bharath,
'Oru naal antha oru naal' is realy superb.
Nobody could add that much expressions except S.JANAKI.
I like the song very much
From: Bharath (@ 192.25.158.12) on: Tue Apr 24 13:29:48 EDT 2001

mani,

1)i agree very much that the song is very very good,
2)i really like it

but both points 1) and 2) are inspite of S.Janaki and because of her.

bye
bharath
From: Kishor Gudapati (@ 32.100.71.61) on: Wed Apr 25 03:08:12 EDT 2001

Hi,

Sujatha is always best.

Voice-10
Pronounciation-10
Variation-10
Bhavam-10
Modulation-10
Versatality-10

Total Scoring is 60/60

Bye
Kishor Gudapati
From: unmaivilambi (@ 63.75.49.120) on: Wed Apr 25 13:30:31 EDT 2001

ore nal antha oru nal from devathai scores mainly because of SJ's voice and modulations.
From: cosmician (@ 194.170.1.130) on: Wed Apr 25 16:00:52 EDT 2001

Nithyashree is the Future (IMO:)...

S (Amazing) - 9
P - 9
V (incredible) - 9.5
M - 9
V - 9

Total : 45.5 / 50
From: Kutty (@ 212.138.47.12) on: Fri Apr 27 04:26:20 EDT 2001

Well, many give 50/50 to their favourite singers. Even the singer himself or herself will not give so much to them if they are told to do a self assessment.
From: tfm fan (@ 203.199.130.155) on: Sat Apr 28 01:56:49 EDT 2001

guys,
I wish you were my teachers/examiners - you are giving marks very generously
From: Amit (@ ) on: Tue Nov 11 00:17:24 EST 2003

chitra 10/10 and yesudas 10/10 for all categories.
From: isaimannan (@ 202.9.168.77) on: Tue Nov 11 04:07:12 EST 2003

basic faults in this rating system.
.
1) no mark for voice (singing..what's that?)
.
2) period not mentioned (f'rinstance, KJY should be rated for 1965-1995, SJ for 1960-1995, and PS for 1958-1993, SPB for 1965-2003)
.
3) pronunciation. is it undrstood, pro only in tamil?
.
4) what's variation? is it same as versatality?
.
5) what's versatality? is a singer who can deliver classical, devotional, and melodiuos film song with the same high quality more versatile (eg. KJY)?, or another who can render melody and fast/dabbanguthu numbers with the same high quality more versatile (eg. SPB)?. personally i would vote KJY here.
.
..and so on..
From: UnniKrishnan's Best Fan (@ 66.185.84.78) on: Tue Nov 11 10:44:00 EST 2003

For UnniKrishnan I'll Give
Singing:9.5 points
Pronounciation 9.5 points
Variation :10 points
Modulation : 10 Points
Versatality : 10 Points
Total points should be 50/49
From: Kumar (@ 61.1.226.6) on: Thu Nov 13 14:33:17 EST 2003

KS Chitra alone gets 50/50.. Unmatched...
From: curses (@ 219.65.108.59) on: Fri Nov 14 11:07:45 EST 2003

UK's best fan..
however fanatic(!) u may be about ur fave singer.. elementary maths shudnt be fuddled with!
It's 49/50! :)
From: fan (@ 206.239.203.2) on: Mon Nov 17 16:07:09 EST 2003

Hariharan
Singing:10
Pronounciation 8.5
Variation :10 points
Modulation : 10 Points
Versatality : 10 Points
Total points should be 48/50
From: fan (@ 206.239.203.2) on: Mon Nov 17 16:08:32 EST 2003

note: hariharan is one of the very few singers who was praised by the great supudu..
From: Raghu (@ 62.172.72.131) on: Mon Nov 24 04:28:26 EST 2003

Singer : Dr.SPB

Singing:100/100

Pronounciation 100/100

Variation :100/100 points

Modulation : 200/100 Points

Versatality : 200/100 Points

voice : 200/100
From: raj (@ 203.197.128.211) on: Mon Nov 24 05:08:00 EST 2003

Why everybody forgot KJ Yesudass..
And also TMS
From: lol (@ 219.65.112.139) on: Mon Nov 24 12:26:10 EST 2003

KAMAL HAASAN

Singing:7 points

Pronounciation 9 points

Variation :6 points

Modulation : 10 Points

Versatality : 10 Points

SO,43/50
From: dubukku (@ 219.65.106.172) on: Thu Nov 27 06:57:53 EST 2003

how about karthik&tippu.
they r leading today.
From: koshi (@ 210.214.132.74) on: Mon Dec 1 07:29:17 EST 2003

SPB
Hariharan
UnniKrishnan
Harish Raghavendra

Chitra
Sujatha
Anuradha Sriram
Swarnalatha
From: suganthi (@ 203.94.67.194) on: Tue Dec 2 01:39:48 EST 2003

Chitra,Sujatha,Harini,Nithyashree,Shreya Ghoshal.Saadana sargam are good female singers.

S.P.B,Hariharan,Unni Krishnan,Harris,Karthik aregood male singers.
From: vinner (@ 217.162.143.133) on: Mon Dec 8 13:21:40 EST 2003

unnikrishnan better than KJ yesudas!

Joke of the millenium!!!!
From: lollu (@ 219.65.106.158) on: Tue Dec 9 03:18:42 EST 2003

harini???
shreya ghoshal???
good joke!!!!!!!
From: unni_fan (@ 165.21.154.10) on: Sat Dec 13 04:37:35 EST 2003

UnniKrishnan is THE best singer ! Join his official fanclub!

http://groups.yahoo.com/group/Ultimate _UnniKrishnan/
From: unnifan (@ 165.21.154.13) on: Sat Dec 13 04:38:05 EST 2003

UnniKrishnan is THE best singer ! Join his official fanclub!

http://groups.yahoo.com/group/Ultimate_UnniKrishnan/
From: UnniKrishnan's Best Fan (@ 66.185.84.78) on: Sat Dec 13 08:53:03 EST 2003

Hi unnifan!
Thankz alot 2 Open da Unnikrishnan Fanz Club once again thankz man.
From: Musicfav (@ ) on: Fri Feb 20 03:08:35 EST 2004

harini,shreya ghoshal are good singers.
From: lollu (@ 219.65.108.171) on: Fri Feb 20 07:52:58 EST 2004

rendum rendu waste!thuthuthu

List all pages of this thread

Back to the Forum

Post comments

Sections: Home - TFM Magazine - Forum - Wiki - POW - oPod - Lyrics - Pictures - Music Notes -
Forums: Current Topics - Ilayaraja Albums - A.R. Rahman Albums - TFM Oldies - Fun & Games
Ilaiyaraja: Releases - News - Share Music - AR Rahman: Releases - News - AOTW - Tweets -
Discussions: MSV - YSR - GVP - Song Requests - Song stats - Raga of songs - Copying - Tweets
Database: Main - Singers - Music Director's - Lyricists Fun: PP - EKB - Relay - Satires - Quiz