Home   Forum   Wiki   Notes   Register   FAQ   Sitemap   About Us   Contact Us  

Why don't more big Directors give chance to YSR?

Topic started by Dirgesh (@ 213.122.206.209) on Fri Sep 21 13:35:56 EDT 2001.
All times in EST +10:30 for IST.

YSR has proved that he produces quality music, but why does he not have a chance to produce good music for good movies?Why don't director's like MA, KB, AP, SC give him chance?

---

Responses:

• From: sats (@ 139.177.224.100) on: Fri Sep 21 15:59:41 EDT 2001
  
  May be his last name is preventing these Directors to give a chance to him IMHO
  
  
• From: UVII (@ 63.225.17.160) on: Fri Sep 21 16:13:13 EDT 2001
  
  sats,
  His last name has only given him a chance in TF industry.....I am sure that is not the problem.
  
  
• From: Bharath (@ 192.25.158.12) on: Fri Sep 21 16:54:36 EDT 2001
  
  see every one has an on going relation ship with a MD. for e.g MR ARR, shankar-ARR, KB-(anyone non-IR), BR-(anyone non-IR).
  
  among these 4 if i have to interpret MR and shankar. they already have some ongoing process with ARR and over the years they wud have smoothened so many aspects of their relationshipa and probably know each other very well to perform effeciently. no one wud want to remove a partnership thats just become productive unless its become unproductive(due to various reasons) .
  
  looks like MR and shankar have a good rapport with ARR and why wud they wanna stop it and experiment with YSR. what wud happen if its flops.
  
  1) it wud be very embarrassing to revert back to ARR
  
  2) for whatever reasons the YSR combo failed the director wud be heaped with critisism saying that lack of ARR made him flop and infact people wud say all the directors sucess was bcoz of ARR.
  (remember IR-BR episode)
  
  point is YSR is available for recruitment but since all comapnies r full he is not getting jobs thats all.
  
  
  
• From: Pradeepa (@ 62.7.17.242) on: Sat Sep 22 05:08:48 EDT 2001
  
  YSR in a combo with a great director could give him the boost he deserves. In Aalavanthaan, instead of Shankar-Ehsan-Loy, the music could have been offered to YSR who has produced more quality music. I think this is S-E-l's first Tamil project and they showed that it was a mistake to hire them.YSR has produced many hit tracks for absolutely terrible movies, so the songs have gone unnoticed.
  I feel that if YSR got a partnership with a big director, (not necessarily KB or MR o Shankar)he would get his just desserts. Let us hope that he gets his big break soon.
  
  
• From: STS (@ 66.42.2.154) on: Sat Sep 22 12:23:25 EDT 2001
  
  Pradeepa,
  I am sure friend Bharath writes another page reply to yours (I already echoed what you have mentioned in other YSR thread)!
  
  looks like MR and shankar have a good rapport with ARR and why wud they wanna stop it and experiment with YSR
  Before MR goes to ARR whom he was working with and how this MR-ARR happened? Similar thing can happen. Reason: Poor KB, now waiting infinitely for ARR's music. Everyone faced this. Frustration will drive. Again KR proved good with DDD. It was hit.
  
  it wud be very embarrassing to revert back to ARR Is this the reason stopping MR to revert to ARR?
  
  lack of ARR made him flop and infact people wud say all the directors sucess was bcoz of ARR Big joke. Iruvar, Thenali etc etc failed because of bad music?
  
  
• From: Jeera (@ 66.27.207.190) on: Sat Sep 22 12:59:08 EDT 2001
  
  First and foremost, don't we want better directors than these four - Three of whom have already spent away all their Ideas - the other one is useless.
  
  
• From: S T S (@ 66.42.1.94) on: Sat Sep 22 13:52:09 EDT 2001
  
  Jeera,
  :-)
  
  
• From: Bharath (@ 24.254.129.235) on: Sat Sep 22 17:13:43 EDT 2001
  
  STS,
  
  to say the millionth time...comment on the comments and not the commentator!
  
  just to prove ( i am tiredof exposing u now b.t.w)that u dont understand english.here is somethings that u overlooked
  
  //"Before MR goes to ARR whom he was working with and how this MR-ARR happened? "//
  
  my post had
  
  //"unless its become unproductive(due to various reasons) . "//
  
  //"Poor KB, now waiting infinitely for ARR's music. Everyone faced this. Frustration will drive"//
  
  poor KB waited for roja and duet and he is soo frustrated that he stupidly chose ARR again... everyone faces this but they r all stupid andgo bak to ARR again... oh why r they all stupid..oh no onehas brains......huh!
  
  flash news...
  KR is doing 500 movies now per year. after the sucess of DDD.
  
  //"Is this the reason stopping MR to revert to ARR? "//
  
  no one will ever know what this means.. MR never needed to revert bak to ARR.
  
  Iruvar failed because of bad music... news to me!
  
  pradeepa infact contradicted what u mentioned in some other thread....and here is my pages of reply to satisfy u...
  
  etho general'a ezhutha vendiyathu...
  
  
  
  
  
  
  
  
  
  
  
  
  
  
  
• From: S T S (@ 66.42.0.162) on: Sat Sep 22 21:33:34 EDT 2001
  
  Bharath,
  I am no more wasting my time replying you. It is like breaking your head against a wall. Keep up your good work.
  
  
• From: Pazhamozhi thatha (@ 210.84.144.171) on: Sat Sep 22 21:54:45 EDT 2001
  
  The menace of stray dogs in this forum has increased off late, who argue and post in a totally irrelevant fashion. I'm going to submit a petition to the Mayor........
  
  
• From: Pradeepa (@ 62.7.115.24) on: Sun Sep 23 08:24:01 EDT 2001
  
  Bharath and STS I don't write on this thread for both of y'all to bring up me as one against either of you. I am simply writing because I happen to this that YSR is a really good MD and I think that he can go really far. Of all the current MD's aside from IR and ARA, YSR is the only one who shows any sort in innovative originality and all I see is people knocking it. Sure I don't deny that some of Vidyasagar and HJ's songs sold, but they are blatant lifts from other songs. Everything of HJ's is a copy of ARR's creativeness.Vidyasagar is the same although he uses a wide range of sources for inspiration. YSR has produced songs that are not copied and it is this quality that I feel will make him be the next longstanding MD in TFM. I think that if he had a good rapport with a director, maybe he would have also been acknowledged as the good MD he is. HJ has been marketed well and given much publicity i.e interviews, reviews and airtime. If YSR had received the same, he too would be the talk of the town for genuine talent. Maybe some magazines or paper wlll feature more of YSR in the near future.
  
  
• From: real rasigan (@ 61.11.79.30) on: Sun Sep 23 18:08:13 EDT 2001
  
  After all u people especially pradeepa have forgotten something.media is not making any hype on non of the music directors (hj).only the soul of the music makes all that hype.even though ysr produces descent music it doesn't captivates people hearts.
  where's see HJ songs right from vaseegara,mudhal kanave,pinju thendrale,poove vai pesum,love pannu.all these songs instantly get inside listeners mind.other wise a movie like 12b with a new face and not much recognized director would have toped the chart in all shops.
  even though the tfm chart shows hj's albums in middle order,go and visit LA top 10,cine south,raaga.com all these sites have placed his albums in top rank.
  
  
• From: real rasigan (@ 61.11.79.37) on: Sun Sep 23 18:09:06 EDT 2001
  
  After all u people especially pradeepa have forgotten something.media is not making any hype on non of the music directors (hj).only the soul of the music makes all that hype.even though ysr produces descent music it doesn't captivates people hearts.
  where's see HJ songs right from vaseegara,mudhal kanave,pinju thendrale,poove vai pesum,love pannu.all these songs instantly get inside listeners mind.other wise a movie like 12b with a new face and not much recognized director would have toped the chart in all shops.
  even though the tfm chart shows hj's albums in middle order,go and visit LA top 10,cine south,raaga.com all these sites have placed his albums in top rank.
  
  

---

List all pages of this thread

---

Back to the Forum

Post comments